james mckay dot net

Astute readers of my blog will note that I turned off my Comment Timeout plugin at the start of this year. I had begun to suspect that its effect on spam was minimal, while at the same time there were still some posts that, according to Google Analytics, attract a bit of attention — in particular, my posts about SharePoint seem to feature rather prominently in searches by people who find the subject even more confusing than I do.

Sooo… now you can even leave comments on my very first blog entry if you are that way inclined.

In the end, I found that turning it off did not result in a noticeable increase in spam comments. I am now using only three plugins to manage spam on my blog and together they put in a stellar performance. Akismet and Bad Behavior stop almost everything dead in its tracks, and beyond that, a blanket rejection of comments that contain BBCode or more than two hyperlinks keeps your spam queue short, makes it easy to check for false positives, and reduces the load that it places on Akismet and your bandwidth consumption. As far as I can tell, 80-90% of spam comments contain either BBCode, or three or more hyperlinks.

However, this raises a question: what is the future of Comment Timeout?

Unfortunately, I have had quite a lot on at work recently and I have other projects that I want to move on to that I simply haven’t had time for so far, so since I am no longer using Comment Timeout myself, maintaining it further now has a very low priority.

There are some things that could still be done on it, such as localisation, but as far as I can tell, it is stable, it works with any version of WordPress since 2.0, and pretty much all the bugs that have been brought to my attention have been ironed out. I haven’t tested it thoroughly against WordPress 2.5, but as far as I can tell it should work properly.

If anyone would like to develop it further, I have no objections. It’s dual licensed under both the GPL and the MIT/X11 licence, so you don’t even need to ask for permission, though it would obviously be nice to get a heads-up.

Comments (1) »

Posted at 13:06 in WordPress plugins